Interior designer Reilly finds herself this Christmas in the town of Mistletoe Lake with no place to stay. She accepts an offer from Ray to stay in his boat, helping him renovate the boat for the town's Christmas Harbor Festival.

Maggie's boss needs a date for the publishing company's Christmas party, and she finds her eleven. Maggie is a successful matchmaker, but what about herself when her ex Jaxson reenters her life?

Chloe conhece o homem perfeito durante o Festival de Natal de sua cidade. No entanto, ele é transferido por seu trabalho e, durante 3 longos anos, eles só voltam a se cruzar nas celebrações do Festival.