When the network announces that her television therapy show is changing to a tabloid shock-fest, a strait-laced and caring psychologist returns to her hometown and reunites with her high school sweetheart. Eventually, she realizes that having someone to share a life with is more important than fame or the excitement of the city.

Após prestar serviços militares, uma enfermeira retorna para a fazenda de sua avó em Amish Country, onde ela encontra um romance inesperado e se vê envolvida em um misterioso caso de assassinato.